Friday, October 31, 2008

Monarchy to Democracy

"The ideas of the ruling class in every epoch the ruling idea i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, consequently also controls he means of material production." This quote seemed pretty simple to me, meaning that the upper class who has the money to control material production  also decides what material will be available and so is the ruling intellectual force. However, the quote became more complicated when we started to talk about the colonization of america and monarchy and democracy. If "each new class puts itself in the place of the ruling class before it" how is it that a change in government can occur. I thought maybe in this case it was because the monarchy of England was so far removed form the colonies that the colonists were able to see a problem with the system.  Also both the colonies and England had control over making necessities for each other; both were dependent on one another. I think that this special situation is what made it possible for the transition from the colonies to go from the class dominated by England's production to the one ruling its own ideology and production. It is true to say that material things affect out ideologies and so the production of a ruling class is bound to control the dependent class. I thought it was interesting that there is a way around this like in the case of the Revolution. 

1 comment:

hope said...

In response to Courtney’s post about the quote, “The ideas of the ruling class in every epoch the ruling idea i.e. the class which is the ruling material force of society is at the same time its ruling intellectual force. The class which has the means of material production at its disposal, consequently also controls he means of material production,” I think the American Revolution is a perfect example. When the colonies were dependent upon England for essential materials, their laws were also governed by England. However, when the American colonies began to have the ability to sustain themselves, they also wanted to rule themselves, thus came about the American Revolution. One of the largest statements the Americans made was to prove to the British that they were no longer dependent upon them for life’s necessities. For example, the Americans overthrew tea in the Boston Harbor (the Boston Tea party), not solely for the amount of destruction of the value of the tea, but to make the statement that a) British imports were no longer needed, and b) British law was no longer welcomed.